The Impact of a Few

My 8th grade history teacher once said, upon teaching about an earthquake that occurred in the Philippines, that “when one person dies it is a tragedy, when 100 people die it is a statistic.” While this is a fairly dark statement for a middle school teacher to make, it has always stuck with me and unfortunately has proven to be true the more I come to understand the world. The death of a few people in a particular tragedy seems to always attract more grief and widespread condolences than an event were many people die. This might have to do with people being able to see themselves in one or two people but not in fifty or more*, so when a mass murder or deaths happen most people cannot even come to envision themselves or their loved ones in that tragic situation.

In the case of the movies we just watched, both 4 Little Girls and Chi-Raq are centered around tragic deaths; however, one movie is made clearly to evoke tears and the other is more nuanced in its approach because of the element of satire. It is not that I think Spike Lee does not want the audience to cry while watching 4 Little Girls and not during Chi-Raq, but one the strategy in presentation of the murders is different. In the beginning of Chi-Raq the viewer is shown statistics on the screen that compare the number of deaths in Chicago to those in the Middle East since 2002. There have been so many people murdered in Chicago that the viewer upon seeing those numbers does not even really get a chance to let them soak in. The number is almost too large to be comprehensible, and because of this the audience begins the film with a different mentality than 4 Little Girls. My theory for this is that four deatimgreshs is easier to swallow and immediately emphasize with than 7,000+. It was interesting to hear the class discussion after both films because while they both center around murder and the loss of Black life, one conversation was outwardly more grievous than the other. I wonder if Spike Lee had that in mind while making Chi-Raq after 4 Little Girls, or if even he himself could not swallow the amount of murders that happen in Chicago and turn the epidemic into something other than a satire, and also why he chose to focus the main plot of the movie on the murder of one little girl.

*That was an arbitrary number to prove a point. In no way am I trying to quantify the importance of life or what should be considered a “mass murder.” I just picked a number substantial higher than two to illustrate a difference in how people might respond in a given tragedy. All life is important.

Screen Shot 2016-04-27 at 12.22.14 AM

 

Advertisements

Author: Dani

Film enthusiast. Firm believer that Spike Lee is the most cerebral filmmaker post Hitchcock.

2 thoughts on “The Impact of a Few”

  1. I definitely agree with your sentiment about the films that the response to 4 Little Girls seemed much more grievous. This is definitely because of the choppiness of tone in Chi-Raq dealing with such serious material but incorporating satire throughout. The one scene where one undeniably does feel pain is during the scene with Jennifer Hudson’s character scrubbing the blood off the cement. I also think that if Lee is going to do a narrative on something like this, it was wise to not try to retell the story of a real murder that happened in Chicago when creating a contemporary film that is not a documentary. So it makes sense that we aren’t introduced to character development of the children in Chi-Raq but rather focus on the over-arching message through this modern greek tragedy form. I wonder what method is more effective though…

    Like

  2. I like this post a lot. You definitely consider both of these films with an objective lens that does not attempt to compare or contrast them, but rather recognize each as a separate conversation surrounding similar issues of senseless death. It’s tough to defend Chiraq at times, but I think Lee chose to include a single death in this complicated film to reel it in to a tangible/traceable event, one that drives Nick Cannon’s character to redemption/consolation

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s